How do profit participation rights differ from ESOP, VSOP and GmbH shares?
Complexity, taxes, liquidity and rights compared.
Real employee shares are GmbH shares: employees become shareholders, with voting rights and an entry in the shareholder list, and every transfer must be notarized. Virtual models such as a VSOP are just a contract promising a payout on exit, taxed as employment income. Profit participation rights (Eigenkapital-Genussrechte) sit in between: employees participate economically like shareholders, without voting rights, without an entry in the commercial register and without a notary.
The table shows how profit participation rights differ from GmbH shares, ESOP and VSOP.
| Profit participation rights | GmbH shares | ESOP | VSOP | |
| Complexity | Contract and profit participation right, digital via beel | Notarization and commercial register | Contract, notary on exercise | Contract |
| Taxes | Employment income on creation (timing can be chosen, deferral under § 19a EStG possible), then capital income | Employment income on acquisition, even without liquidity (dry income), then capital income | Employment income on exercise, then capital income | Entire payout as employment income, usually only on exit |
| Liquidity | Transferable, secondary market possible | Transferable only via notary | Usually not transferable | Not transferable |
| Rights | Economically like shareholders from creation, plus put option | Like shareholders | Like shareholders from exercise | Usually exit proceeds only |
| Voting rights | No voting rights | Voting rights | Voting rights from exercise | No voting rights |
How taxation works in detail: How is employee participation with profit participation rights taxed?
How employee participation works with beel: How does employee participation with beel work? What it costs: What does employee participation cost?
beel does not provide legal or tax advice. This article is for information purposes only. Tax treatment depends on the individual case. Please consult a tax advisor for specific questions.